Constitutional Court A Structural Solution to the Misruling Problems of the Political System?

Authors

  • Gideon Doron Tel Aviv University Author
  • Assaf Meidani The Academic College of Tel Aviv-Yaffo Author

Keywords:

Constitutional Court, Judicial System in Israel, Relations between Politics and Law, Public Policy, Governmental Arrangements, Alternative Political Culture, Ungovernability of the Political System, High Court of Justice

Abstract

At the beginning of January 2002 the Israeli parliament rejected a primary bill, served two years earlier for establishing a constitutional court. This article will elaborate on the legislation process and place it as a phase in the development of a public-political discussion on the demand for a special constitutional court, outside the judicial system, that will be exclusively engaged in constitution criticism.

This article focuses on the question of the necessity of a special constitutional court from the political point of view: the factors putting the subject on the public agenda, and the process in which political players wish to set a public policy, meaning a structural change in the ordinances of government.

The main claim in the article stresses the deep rips in society, and the existence of an alternative political culture together with the existent institutional structure, present difficulties on the political system when trying to cope with problems complying with the design of public policy – a problem named in literature as ‘misruling of the political system’. The difficulties of ruling have developed a pattern of increased appeals to the High Court of Justice, for help in the public decision making process or compelling the politicians to change the existing institutional structure. This article strives to find solutions that will advance the ruling capabilities of the political system, in a way so that public policy can be formulated also in matters that are considered principal to the Israeli society.

In the existing political culture today, a constitutional court will not be a solution for a misruling problem of the system. At most it will be a mechanism that will probably face a varied amount of resistance from different interest groups that will not be happy with the quality and quantity of the supply of policy.

Published

2007-07-01

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Doron, G., & Meidani, A. (2007). Constitutional Court A Structural Solution to the Misruling Problems of the Political System? IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 17, 319-343. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/482