Facing the Diaspora: Jewish Art Discourse in 1930s Eretz Israel

Authors

  • Dalia Manor Bezalel Academy of Arts and Design Jerusalem Author

Keywords:

Israeli art, Jewish art, Jewish identity, Diaspora, Gazith journal, Waldemar George, art criticism

Abstract

The one period overlooked in the history of Israeli art is the 1930s. This is conspicuous in comparison to the wealth of material dedicated to the 1920s and to later periods, and in view of the significant developments during the 1930s in the art field including the founding of major art institutions. The critical discourse on art that converged with the discourse on Jewish identity may have contributed to this marginalization.

A prevalent idea of the time was that art made by Jewish artists shares a common quality, which is ‘to be sought in the hidden racial elements, in the mystery of the Jewish soul.’ The notion of Jewish race and Jewish soul were key concepts in writing on art, particularly in the journal Gazith, the then main platform for art discourse. Especially influential were the views of French critic Waldemar George published in Hebrew. He argued that the spirituality of Jewish art means that it is detached from any national or territorial base. The admiration pronounced by Gazith for Jewish artists in Paris as a model for artists in Palestine added to this hitherto unnoticed important ideological shift. It was accompanied by a stylistic change that has been noticed and heavily criticized.

The reception of these ideas by artists and writers in Eretz Israel deserves attention: art was no longer identified with the national revival in the Land of Israel as it was in the previous decades. Instead, artists turned their faces to the Diaspora and the experience of suffering as a new paradigm for modern Jewish art. In later years the concept of Jewish manifestation in art was rejected and scorned (until the 1980s) and with it the art of the 1930s.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Manor, D. (2015). Facing the Diaspora: Jewish Art Discourse in 1930s Eretz Israel. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 13-51. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/536