Aspects of the Negation of Diaspora

Authors

Keywords:

Anti-Semitism, Jewish Problem, Zionism, Negation of Diaspora, New Jew, Assimilation, Holocaust Memory, Holocaust Survivors

Abstract

The rise of anti-Semitism in nineteenth-century Europe brought about the socalled ‘Jewish problem’. How were Jews to be perceived within the gradually established bourgeois society, after the French Revolution and the spreading Industrial Revolution? Were they a religion? A people? A nation? Each possible answer would cause a specific problem pertaining to their integration into the newly built society. Three fundamental strategies were adopted in order to confront the ‘problem’: assimilation, socialism, and Zionism.

The Zionist solution, though a result of the nineteenth-century’s national movements, differed from any other nation-state building in Europe: It lacked the unity of territory, the unity of a collective population inhabiting this territory, and even the cultural unity embodied in a consolidated national language. Thus, Zionism was constituted ex negativo, relying on the two postulates ‘Negation of Diaspora’ and the birth of the ‘new jew’. This is why everything Jewish, reminiscent of ‘Diaspora’, was pejoratively perceived and fought to be erased; even Yiddish, the language of Eastern European Jewry. And this explains the essentially ambivalent relationship of Zionistic Israel to the Shoah and its survivors: While instrumentalizing the memory of the Shoah as an argument for the ideological justification of Zionism’s political way, it related to the survivors themselves as incarnations of the Diasporic Jews. This had some tragic consequences.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Zuckermann, M. (2015). Aspects of the Negation of Diaspora. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 232-239. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/549