'Homeland' and 'Diaspora' in American Jewish Textbooks, 1928-1948

Authors

Keywords:

American Jewry, Jewish Textbooks, New Yishuv, Zionism, Jewish Education, American Jewish Identity, Acculturation, American Frontier

Abstract

This article traces the way in which the New Yishuv and its underlying ideology were depicted in American Jewish schoolbooks between 1920 and 1948. Zionist ideology and the upbuilding of Palestine posed a potential challenge to American Jews’ perceptions of Self and Other. At a time when American Jewish educators were emphasizing Jewish unity, Zionist ideologues and politicians were drawing value-laden distinctions between Diaspora Jews and members of the New Yishuv, particularly the halutzim. American Jews adamantly rejected any ideology that placed in question the viability of the American Jewish community or American Jews’ loyalty to the United States government. As such, while Zionism and Jewish state building were accorded enthusiastic treatment, they were portrayed primarily as a solution to Jewish problems in Europe. Authors adamantly rejected the notion that American Jews were in physical danger and in need of a Jewish homeland.

Textbook authors drew upon American imagery and myths in portraying Palestine. Moreover, given the perceived affinities between the Yishuv and the American frontier, American Zionist textbooks were able to serve as agents of acculturation even as they stressed Jewish nationalism and bolstered ethnic cohesion. They also contributed to a widening chasm between the real Israel and the Israel of the American Jewish imagination.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Krasner, J. B. (2015). ’Homeland’ and ’Diaspora’ in American Jewish Textbooks, 1928-1948. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 227-254. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/569