Where to Have the Baby? The National Laws for Parturition During the British Mandate

Authors

  • Omi Leissner Independent researcher Author

Keywords:

Hospital childbirth, Medicalization of childbirth, Midwives, Physicians, Hadassah, Mother-and-child clinics, Nation building, Mandate period, Eretz-Israel

Abstract

During the twentieth century parturition in the industrialized world shifted from the home to the hospital. In the absence of proof attesting to its health benefits, researchers tend to view this process as a function of competing interests, especially between those of doctors and midwives (the traditional birth assistants). In Eretz-Israel in the 1940s, the rate of Jewish births in hospitals reached ninety percent. The article traces the various local interests that underlie that figure. 

Specifically, on the basis of archival material related to the Hadassah Organization (and Mother-and-Child Clinics set up by Hadassah during the Mandate) I claim that here too a professional battle may be discerned. Although the doctors at first supported ‘power-sharing’ with the midwives, they gradually made an increasing number of decisions in their own favor. 

In any case, the doctors obviously did not act alone in their drive to have mothers hospitalized during parturition. The clinic nurses backed by Hadassah encouraged, if not coerced, the women to give birth in hospitals. It also appears that most women were eager to comply with these dictates. This scenario correlates with the findings of historians who have recently noted the powerful influence wielded by the Zionist medical authorities in the name of Israeli ‘nation-building.’

Published

2011-07-01

How to Cite

Leissner, O. (2011). Where to Have the Baby? The National Laws for Parturition During the British Mandate. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 336-366. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/647