Women's Meeting Points in the Early Days of the 'New Yishuv' (1878-1918): A Look of Their Writings

Authors

Keywords:

Women’s community, Women’s solidarity, First Aliya, Second Aliya, The New Woman, Women’s writing, Gender equality, Male hegemony, Carol Gilligan, Phyllis Chesler

Abstract

The article traces the development of the women's community in the beginning of the Jewish colonization in Eretz-Israel, through the writings of women of the first aliyot (immigrations): Women-settlers of the First Aliya and women-laborers of the Second Aliya.

Reviewing the writings of these women (documents, diaries, letters, memoirs, short stories) exposes other sectors of women whom they encountered in daily life: Women born in the Old Jewish Yishuv (Jerusalem, Safed, Tiberias), Oriental-Sephardic as well as European-Ashkenazi; Yemenite women immigrated to Eretz-Israel (1882, 1908,1912); Arabic women with whom relationships were either commercial or domestic (employment).

The article studies the activity and solidarity among the new-comers women seeking their identity as the 'New Woman' in the national life of the country and in their struggle for equality and rights (in the private and public spheres). Two basic questions are addressed: to what degree did women's marginal status in all areas of male society motivate them to act as a united force regardless of their religious, ideological, ethnic, or national affiliation; and, did the level of their activity proceed according to Carol Gilligan's 'developing moral model' (in the sense of communication and giving) or Phyllis Chesler's 'ambivalent subversive model' (based on competition and 'indirect aggression')?

The conclusion drawn is that even if the women's community in the early waves of Zionist immigration managed to create a socialization of 'women for women', it generally remained in either internal, separatist collective frameworks or on parallel competitive tracks. In reality, it remained perpetually stuck in a kind of dialectical linkage between Gilligan's and Chesler's models. Despite the efforts that went into meetings and discourses for boundary crossing, women were constrained by ideological and socioeconomic tensions to remain loyal to the dominant male hegemony, even though this hegemony excluded them from its affairs.

Published

2011-07-01

How to Cite

Berlovitz, Y. (2011). Women’s Meeting Points in the Early Days of the ’New Yishuv’ (1878-1918): A Look of Their Writings. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 369-408. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/648