Rabbi Shagar and Cultural Feminism

Authors

Keywords:

Rabbi Shagar, Women’s status, Torah study for women, Cultural feminism, Postmodernism, Halakhic discourse, The female voice, Masculine epistemology, Maimonides, Beit Halevi, Menachem Mendel Schneerson

Abstract

Rabbi Shimon Gershon Rosenberg (hereafter, Rabbi Shagar) was one of the most original thinkers in the Orthodox discourse in the last decade. His writing on post-modernism’s influence on religious life offers a model in which the disintegration of borders, due to the impact of post-modernism, becomes a springboard for advances in religious life within the traditional Jewish legal framework. One of the key issues he dealt with was women’s status. He identified the change in the woman’s place in the public sphere as one of the major transformations in modern living, and insisted that the religious legal discourse relate to this change. Much of his work focuses on the cultural/attitudinal feminism school. Cultural feminism, sometimes termed attitudinal or behavioral feminism, is devoted to the uniqueness of the female nature, at the same time it is perpetually criticized for its justification of female nature as defined by the patriarchal establishment. Rabbi Shagar agreed that this was a very serious, complex judgment but added that Jewish religious law was capable of coping with a sanctified past by employing pragmatic argument, such as the male’s role in Torah study and the female’s role in family care, and that these arguments allow a certain degree of adoption of modern values (even though supporters of modernism often regard the pace of this internalization as too slow). Unlike the works of other Orthodox thinkers who are either ignorant of feminist writing or familiar with only the basic texts, Rabbi Shagar devoted much time and energy in studying these texts and became an expert on feminist writing. The article deals with two of his articles on Talmud Torah for women. Rabbi Shagar examined the religious legal model of Talmud Torah for women and its link to cultural/ attitudinal feminism. Rabbi Shagar presented his own vision of Talmud Torah for women. His texts in the religious legal discourse were unique in that they made wide use of philosophical tools and were often based on worldviews associated with cultural feminism. He dealt with the ‘woman’s voice’, not by relegating it to traditional masculine frameworks, but by seeing the great advantage it had in being freed from masculine epistemology. The contribution of the ‘woman’s voice’ to Torah study lies in its innovation.

The first article deals with Maimonides’ religious legal view of Talmud Torah for women on which Jewish legal discussion is based. It offers an original commentary based on philosophical tools, and compares the terminology and views in the Mishneh Torah with those in the Guide for the Perplexed. In the second article I discuss Beit-Halevi’s reply and compare it to the original position of the Ramam (Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson of Lubavitch).

Published

2011-07-01

How to Cite

Fuchs, I. (2011). Rabbi Shagar and Cultural Feminism. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 771-789. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/668