Home in the Diaspora and Diaspora at Home: Representations of Diasporic Domesticity in Zionist Domestic Discourse

Authors

  • Michal Chacham Shenkar College of Engineering, Design and Art, Open University of Israel Author

Keywords:

Zionist Domestic Discourse, Domesticity, Hygiene, Eugenics, Orientalism, Diasporic Memory, Nostalgia, Modernity

Abstract

Jewish domesticity in Mandate Palestine–Eretz Israel and in the early years of the State of Israel is discussed in this paper within the framework of what I delineate as ‘Zionist Domestic Discourse’. Zionist culture was intensively engaged not only in establishing national territory, but also in inventing domestic space. Within this discursive framework Zionist domesticity emerges in dichotomist opposition to the historical and literary accounts of the misery and wretchedness of Jewish domestic life in East-European Shtetls, later to be associated with the unhygienic lifestyle of the old Jewish settlement in Palestine; the so-called domestic primitivism of the rural Palestinian population; and what was extensively described as backward domestic habits brought by Jewish immigrants from their diasporic origins in Islamic countries.

Zionist domestic discourse originates in an earlier domestic discourse manifested in turn of the twentieth century Zionist utopia and in a medical-hygienist discourse held by Zionist Jewish physicians who were deeply concerned with the physical regeneration of the Jews. The utopian domestic discourse was informed by the establishment of the racial paradigm as a scientific paradigm within the European scientific discourse of the era. This racial discourse stemmed from Hygienist and Eugenic thought; both had a crucial effect on Jewish identity discourse and undoubtedly on early domestic thought.

Within Zionist domestic discourse in Mandate Palestine and the early years of the State of Israel, literary and visual representations of the diasporic home played a dual role. I argue that while the hygienist image of the modern home cannot emerge devoid of its orientalist mirror-image of the diasporic home, mirror-imaging is not the only foundation upon which Zionist domesticity is constructed. Nostalgic representations also play a crucial part. This paper discusses how nurturing diasporic memory holds two distinct, contradicting yet complementary, roles: the first, antagonistic, the second, nostalgic – when the diasporic home becomes the object of longing and nostalgic indulgence, even amidst the distinct agents of domestic modernity.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Chacham, M. (2015). Home in the Diaspora and Diaspora at Home: Representations of Diasporic Domesticity in Zionist Domestic Discourse. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 83-121. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/543