Exile and Diaspora: Two Zionisms

Authors

Keywords:

Zionism, Negation of Exile, Zionist Narrative, Maximalist Interpretation, Minimalist Interpretation, Essentialist-Proprietary Interpretation, Constructivist-Egalitarian Interpretation

Abstract

From its inception Zionism was beset by debates about how to interpret the doctrine of the negation of exile. Under a maximalist interpretation, it entailed an absolute rejection of any Jewish life outside the Land of Israel; it was a principle according to which no Jew should live in exile. Under a minimalist interpretation it entailed that not all Jews should live in exile, denying only that the totality of Jewish existence should lie outside the Land of Israel. The maximalist interpretation came to dominate mainstream Zionism from at least as early as the 1930s. However, it has softened from the 1980s onward.

I distinguish in the paper between two interpretations of the Zionist narrative: an essentialist-proprietary interpretation and a constructivistegalitarian interpretation. After explicating some major practical implications of the first interpretation, I argue that from the perspective of the essentialist-proprietary version of Zionism, the transition from a maximalist to a minimalist interpretation of the negation of exile can only be explained by pragmatic and tactical considerations, and cannot be explained by principled considerations. After explaining the constructivist-egalitarian interpretation of Zionism, I show how this approach implies the transition from the maximalist interpretation of the negation of exile to its minimalist interpretation as a matter of principle.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Gans, C. (2015). Exile and Diaspora: Two Zionisms. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 204-231. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/548