The Dialectics of Demonization in the Israeli Identity Discourse

Authors

  • Alon Gan Kibbutzim College of Education, Technology and the Arts image/svg+xml Author

Keywords:

Negation of Exile, Negation of the Negation, Israeli Identity, Jewish Identity, Exilic Identity, Tzabar, Demonization, Identity Discourse

Abstract

‘The purpose of Zionism is to purge and purify true Judaism from the scum and filth of exile … Zionism demands to remove and obliterate all this pollution and filth’ (I. H. Tavyov, ‘Segula Laashirut’ [‘A Talisman for Richness’], Hamagid, March 13, 1900).

‘Don’t you see that the time is ripe for education? ... Diasporic education … is aimed, first and foremost, at an ethical-creative way of life, which derives from the diasporic philosophy and from the exilic idea in Judaism’ (Likrat Hinuch Legalutiyut [Toward A Diasporic Education], Resling 2004, pp. 192-193).

The first of these two quotations was written in the beginning of the twentieth century, and the second in the beginning of the twenty-first. While the first demands ‘to remove and obliterate all the pollution and filth’ of exile, the second seeks to adopt a ‘diasporic philosophy’ and educate for an exilic worldview. This pendulum swing points to a reversal of the objects of glorification and demonization. With almost the same rage and totality with which the pioneers eradicated the ‘old Jew’, the ‘exilic Jew’, some intellectuals and academics now want to carry out a process of murdering ‘the oppressive Tzabar (a Jewish native of Israel) mentality’. The demonization of the Tzabar entity constitutes an antithesis to the demonization of the exilic one.

This article seeks to follow basic processes in the formation of the attitude toward the ethos of the rejection of the exile over time, while attempting to point to a gradual shift from rejecting the exile to rejecting the rejection, and to opening an identity discourse that tries to integrate the Israeli essence and the Jewish one as complementary, rather than colliding, entities.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Gan, G. (2015). The Dialectics of Demonization in the Israeli Identity Discourse. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 375-402. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/556