Diaspora or State in Jewish National Historiography

Authors

Keywords:

Jewish historiography, Israel–Diaspora relations, Shimon Dubnov, Jewish nationalism, Zionism, Historical consciousness, Babylon and Jerusalem, Jewish identity

Abstract

This article examines the relationship between the Diaspora and Jewish authority in the Land of Israel in the view of modern Jewish historiography. The article analyzes historiography in the broad sense, which also relates to the formation of consciousness of the past by academic historians, thinkers, and leaders. In the period of the foundation of Jewish national historiography, in the work of Shimon Dubnov and those who followed him, we witness a coherent, unified narrative of Jewish history. The argument between the Zionist school and Diaspora nationalism related to the question of whether the national Jewish center could only be in the Land of Israel, or whether a national center could exist in the Diaspora as well. The Zionist historians described Jewish history as a process leading to the center of government in Palestine. In contrast, Jewish historians in the Diaspora preferred the elliptical model, which recognized two centers – ‘Babylon and Jerusalem’. In the reality that developed in the 1980s and ‘90s, the definition of the term ‘diaspora’ became vaguer, since many other ethnic and economic groups word-wide used this term to define themselves. Thus in this period, the borders of consciousness that defined the Diaspora versus the Jewish state were blurred. The global nature of Jewish studies also demonstrates that we no longer stand between two poles – Israel as opposed to the Diaspora. Today, the question of whether historiography can supply a model of a shared future for Israel and the Diaspora remains open, but is vital for the future of Jewish historiography as well as Jewish identity.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Conforti, Y. (2015). Diaspora or State in Jewish National Historiography. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 137-170. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/566