Jews’ Political Experience in the Post-Statist Configuration: The Case of Raymond Aron and Hannah Arendt

Authors

Keywords:

Emancipation, European Jewry, State of Israel, Raymond Aron, Hannah Arendt, Six-Day War, Zionism, Political Experience, Nation-State

Abstract

This article explores the relationship between emancipated Jews in Europe who are citizens of their nation-state with the Jewish state, defined as the solution to the so-called Jewish problem in Europe. I argue that the political semantics at hand are not adjusted to grasp this relationship and propose to adopt a sociological perspective on political experience. Aron and Arendt’s vivid emotional reaction to the Six-Day War is taken as a typical experience of the Jews in the post-statist configuration. Their political philosophy, their link to Zionism, as well as their personal biography are very different, but their common fear of the potential trauma of 1967 is quite similar. This emotional reaction, which they both avoid explaining, is embedded in the Jewish historical experience of emancipation in France and Germany. The State of Israel, once founded, appears as a kind of ersatz of the protective entity Jews always needed and sought, but which the modern state in Europe, after WW II, is unable to fulfill. This is why the State of Israel only emerges, for them, even when they are indifferent or hostile to Zionism, as a consistent political actor in the moment of its potential destruction.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Trom, D. (2015). Jews’ Political Experience in the Post-Statist Configuration: The Case of Raymond Aron and Hannah Arendt. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 331-348. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/574