Return to Zion Beyond the Dialectic of Exile

Authors

Keywords:

Galut (Exile), Gola (Diaspora), Return to Zion, Doctrine of Exile, Hebraic Anthropology, Divine Presence, Transcendence, Zionism, Ultra-Orthodoxy

Abstract

The Israeli experience shattered the symbolic economy of exile (Galut). From now on, exile is questioned in the light of the return (shivat Zion) that contemporary Israel embodies. This upheaval generates various attitudes facing Jewish existence, from Zionist to ultra-orthodox. The author puts the new configuration back in a historical viewpoint. He enumerates five ‘economies’ of exile (and return). In order to deepen the challenges coming from such a development, he revisits the notion of galut, which is not related to an uprooting or a violent expulsion but rather refers to a permanent datum of the Hebraic anthropology in its relationship to the world. The two foundational narratives for the Jews refer to exile (from Ur and Egypt); that is to say they come before the settling in Eretz Israel, so that exile precedes the settling in a land that ‘is’ not Canaan but Eretz Israel. Concerning the return, according to the spirit of the exile doctrine, it is not supposed to be a return to a point of departure but to the origin, the ‘reshit’, which precedes it and stands beyond any temporality or at the source of temporality. From this viewpoint, if the Gola (diaspora) (which, according to the author, has a strictly political meaning) finishes is gone, the Galut as such does not end. It is related to the idea that the divine presence is not representable so that it is absent in the real world, this absence being the means of the relationship between naturality and supernaturality (transcendence). This is the profound meaning of exile, in its metaphysical and symbolical dimension.

Published

2015-07-01

How to Cite

Trigano, T. (2015). Return to Zion Beyond the Dialectic of Exile. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 349-362. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/576