Secular Theology: Israeli Secular Criticism through the Prism of Hans Jonas’ Thought

Authors

  • Avner Dinur Sapir Academic College, Kibbutzim College of Education, Technology and the Arts Author

Keywords:

Hans Jonas, Secular Theology, Jewish Secular Identity, Judaism as a Culture, Secularism, Creation Myths, Image of God, Moral Responsibility

Abstract

The theological works of Hans Jonas can be taken as a critique of Israeli thinkers who speak in the name of ‘Jewish secular identity’ and ‘Judaism as a culture’. Many of these thinkers view secularism as a historical and sociological phenomenon rather than as a way of thinking and set of beliefs. Others are so occupied with their struggle against religiously observant Jews that their portrait of secular Jewry looks like a weak antithesis of the former.

The first part of the paper examines a number of Israeli thinkers and shows that their ideas on secularism are split between the need to say something positive about secular identity and their admission that secularism is nothing but the negation of religion and therefore lacks any positive content.

The second part briefly presents Hans Jonas and his theological writings. Jonas had a number of original ideas about the nature of God and the creation myths. He believed that the idea that man was created ‘in God’s image’ put a burden of responsibility on humans. The term ‘secular theology’ in Jonas’s work refers to the use of the term ‘God’ as one of the theology’s main pillars even though the theology remained essentially secular.

The third part of the article describes ‘secular theology’ as a school of thought that straddles the line between secular and religious while challenging both. It is secular in that it is free of tradition, ritual, worship, sets of beliefs, rabbis, and religious communities and institutions, but it is also theological in that it accepts the idea of God as the basis for some of its philosophical and ethical claims.

Published

2014-07-01

How to Cite

Dinur, A. (2014). Secular Theology: Israeli Secular Criticism through the Prism of Hans Jonas’ Thought. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 160-184. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/587