The Revolt within the Revolt: The Struggle of the Women of Ein Harod to Pull Guard Duty in 1936

Authors

Keywords:

Ein Harod, Labor Movement, United Kibbutz Movement, Women in the kibbutz, Gender equality, Guard duty and defense, Arab Revolt, The Yishuv

Abstract

From its inception Kibbutz Ein Harod was one of the dominant collectives in the Labor Movement and Zionist land settlement. Ein Harod was also the home of Yitzhak Tabenkin, one of the leaders of the United Kibbutz Movement, and other powerful figures wielding ideological, organizational, economic and political clout, such as Shlomo Lavi, Aharon Zisling, Haimn Sturman, Luba Levita, Reuven (Vinia) Cohen and Gershon Ostrovsky. The only element missing in this picture is the women.

The article assumes that Ein Harod’s strength as a key player in shaping the Labor Movement – setting aside the endless internal tensions and stormy ideological clashes – cannot be properly understood without analyzing the part played by the kibbutz’s female members. Gender was a basic issue in the women’s effort to integrate into the collective life, advance their personal and social status in the collective, and uphold pioneering and egalitarian ideals. Gender was the basic level in their struggle to determine their own destiny and the success of the Zionist enterprise. At Ein Harod women made up nearly half the population. Their activity in the public domain was the driving force behind behavior norms and the way things were run. Their influence went far beyond Ein Harod’s courtyard and the Jezreel Valley.

I prove this theoretical presumption by examining a number of Ein Harod women – Eva Tabenkin, Shulamit Zharnovskaya, and Lilia Basvitch – and their struggle to pull guard duty in the first phase of the Arab Revolt in 1936. Their success may have been brief but it was a breakthrough, albeit mostly a symbolic one, in the stated aim of Jewish women in the Yishuv to play an active role in defense and perimeter security. The women regarded this as the frontlines for gaining equal rights and shouldering responsibility in building the Jewish national homeland.

The article is based on protocols from Ein Harod members’ meetings and women’s special discussion groups, kibbutz newsletters, contemporary correspondence, and articles from Mibifnim, Tzror Michtavim, and Dvar Hapo’elet.

Published

2011-07-01

How to Cite

Chazan, M. (2011). The Revolt within the Revolt: The Struggle of the Women of Ein Harod to Pull Guard Duty in 1936. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 50-81. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/632