Zionism, Masculinity and Feminism

Authors

  • Orit Kamir The Israeli Center for Human Dignity Ltd Author

Keywords:

Zionism, Feminism, Masculinity, Diasporic femininity, Women’s liberation, Liberal feminism, Cultural feminism, Dominance feminism, Gender equality, Respect-based feminism

Abstract

This article focuses on two questions: Why was Zionism not more of a feminist movement at its outset and, how can it recreate itself to become more feminist? This inquiry offers a fresh understanding of Israel’s past and suggests an agenda for contemporary Zionist and Israeli studies. Other questions dealt with the historical background that precluded a more feminist Zionism; the ways in which contemporary Zionism can become more profeminist; and the ‘type’ of feminism that Zionism can come to terms with.

The article claims that at the turn of the twentieth century Zionism was, inter alia, a men’s liberation movement that sought to free the Jewish male from his diasporic femininity. As such, Zionism’s basic principles clashed with the interests of every woman’s liberation movement. Zionism could not tolerate the feminist assertion that all humans are social equals (‘liberal feminism’). It rejected the feminist argument that feminine traits are as worthy as masculine ones (‘cultural feminism’), and the feminist demand that women, as a group, are entitled to equal social power (‘dominance feminism’). Zionism’s celebrated ‘egalitarianism’ merely meant that Zionist women were obliged to help the men-folk in national redemption and masculinization. A century later, Zionism’s survival depends on its ability to recreate itself and adapt its masculine outlook to universal human values. This transformation will make it compatible with Israel’s respect-based feminism.

Published

2011-07-01

How to Cite

Kamir, O. (2011). Zionism, Masculinity and Feminism. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 443-470. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/654