‘The Purpose of Creation is Man’ Women’s Status in a Polemic on Marital Therapy in Haredi (Ultra-Orthodox) Societies

Authors

Keywords:

Hirsch Travis, Menashe Klein, Pirkei Hanhagat Ha’Bayit, Women’s status, Patriarchy, Feminine epistemology, Marital partnership, Women’s religious aspirations, Halakha, Ultra-Orthodox Judaism

Abstract

The article examines Hirsch Travis’s book Pirkei Hanhagat Ha’Bayit (Lessons in Household Management) and the debate on its publication in the late 1970s, especially by the renowned halakhic (traditional Jewish legal) judge, Rabbi Menashe Klein.

Travis’ book is far from a modern approach toward women’s status despite its impression as a modern, professional composition supportive of women’s needs, desires and whims. Furthermore, Travis scorns feminine intelligence and denies the woman’s legitimacy in the geminate organ. He excludes her from the male partner’s estate, positing her merely as an object, a catalyst in the true relationship that men should aspire to – a religious connection to God.

Klein criticizes Travis’s patriarchal point of view, even though the latter does not negate feminine epistemology to an extreme degree. Since Klein believes that women are capable of relating to men in a true partnership, he legitimizes female religious ambitions. He holds that the orthodox lifestyle (contrary to Travis’ claims) enhances both the patriarchal system and feminine epistemology. He protests Travis’s humiliating attitude toward women, attributing it to the scourge of modern influences. Thus, Klein, the ultra-orthodox mentor, expresses semi-egalitarian views despite his patriarchal beliefs.

Published

2011-07-01

How to Cite

Hershkowitz, I. (2011). ‘The Purpose of Creation is Man’ Women’s Status in a Polemic on Marital Therapy in Haredi (Ultra-Orthodox) Societies. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 623-647. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/662