Activism and Moderation Regarding the Use of Force: Brenner, Gordon and ‘Hapoel Hatzair’

Authors

Keywords:

Aharon David Gordon, Yosef Haim Brenner, Second Aliya, Hapoel Hatzair, Use of Force, Labor Movement, Ahuzat Bayit, Jewish Legion, Tel-Hai, Haganah, May 1921 Riots

Abstract

Aharon David Gordon and Yosef Haim Brenner were the spiritual leaders of the immigrants who arrived to Palestine during the Second Aliya. This article examines their attitudes towards the use of force by analyzing the connection between their stands and those of Hapoel Hatzair, a party that had reservations regarding the use of force in realizing Zionist goals. Two main questions are discussed: first, what particular stance did Brenner and Gordon adopt when the issue of using force arose in practice. The second, whether any commonalities can be detected between their attitudes at different junctions and toward different kinds of use of force. Against this background, the article considers several topics: the debate on the use of violence during the construction of Ahuzat Bayit in 1909, Gordon’s and Brenner’s attitudes toward defense activities, the controversy over volunteering to the Jewish Legion in 1918, the debates about the defense of Tel-Hai in 1920, the establishment of the Haganah and the outbreak of the May 1921 riots.

The main conclusion of the article is that at times of crisis, the particular attitudes of Gordon and Brenner did not determine the behavior of the young immigrants of the Second Aliya. Examining this issue, which has not been sufficiently explored in the historical research, can contribute not only to clarifying Gordon’s and Brenner’s stands on these various topics, but also to understanding the Labor Movement in its early days.

Published

2008-07-01

How to Cite

Chazan, M. (2008). Activism and Moderation Regarding the Use of Force: Brenner, Gordon and ‘Hapoel Hatzair’. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 239-261. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/687