The Brenner- Gordon Debate and its Influence on the Israeli Labor Movement

Authors

Keywords:

Yosef Haim Brenner, Philosophical Anthropology, Despair, Nevertheless, Moral Choice, Will to Live, Categorical Imperative, Pioneering Fulfillment, Second Aliya, Third Aliya

Abstract

Brenner’s “practicality” and Gordon’s “impracticality” are imbedded in the difference between their different perceptions of the “doctrines on humanity.” Gordon believed that a person can — both as an individual and as part of a collective — transcend the level of existence in which he is presently immersed. Progress is necessary for two reasons: In terms of the nature of a human existence and in terms of the chances for survival. The evolution of humanity has reached a point of no return that demands a decision be made between destruction and rising to a new level of inter-human and inter-national relations, that can be achieved with the power of moral choice, and not through force inflicted by authority. He believed that individuals who became conscious of the inevitability of despair with all “practical” solutions would affect the change and constitute the ideal for their nation and for all nations.

Brenner based his “nevertheless” term (in which he justified the pioneering determination to fulfill the impossibility of the Zionist idea by settling the land and building a vigorous Jewish society) on the confrontation between the irrational, burning human desire and awareness of the imminent annihilation. Like Gordon, Brenner thought that despair derived from direct contemplation with truth would be the deciding factor. The difference between them was highlighted again on the anthropological level: Brenner identifies with the Darwinist will to live while Gordon identifies with the creative life experience that becomes a “categorical imper ative” which instigates existential change. This is a fundamental difference between the ambition to exist “normally” and the recognition that only the establishment of different, more moral values can save humanity and the nation of Israel from extinction.

The solution appears paradoxical: The influence of Brenner’s concept of despair on the second and third aliyot (immigrations) overpowered Gordon’s concept of despair, despite the fact that Gordon suggested a path in which the ag o ny of fulfillment means superior humanity, while Brenner only suggested a farfetched change for a meager existence in the future.

Published

2008-07-01

How to Cite

Schweid, E. (2008). The Brenner- Gordon Debate and its Influence on the Israeli Labor Movement. IYUNIM: Multidisciplinary Studies in Israeli and Modern Jewish Society, 263-273. https://iyunim.bgu.ac.il/index.php/iyunim/article/view/688